Off the Beaten Path of Enlightenment
07/15/07 10:46 AMA few years ago I sought out a fairly well-known book in the field of spirituality, The Celestine Prophecy. It's the story of an unemployed teacher who travels to Peru to research ancient scrolls that reveal ways to look at and walk through life that produce greater harmony. The Celestine Prophecy being a novel (which at least one person I know did not disappointingly realize until the last chapter), I had difficulty separating the philosophical concepts from the fictional elements. I'm more accustomed to receiving undisguised wisdom and enjoying fantastical narratives as two different experiences.
It's no surprise, then, that I was underwhelmed by The Celestine Prophecy's movie adaptation. Though the cast features the marvelous Hector Elizondo looking spiffy in his cardinal robes, the main characters, played by Tom Welling and Sigourney Weaver look-alikes, are just dull. John, the ex-teacher, is nothing more than a patsy for his companions and a foil for their insights. Everyone around him seems to know more than him, and they offer their superiority in little nuggets such as, "There's more to the world than you can see." It suggests an arrogance I normally associate with churches and cults. John isn't questioning of his role in life but is a victim of circumstances. Nobody becomes enlightened kicking and screaming.
Even his coming over to the dark side doesn't offer the audience much inspiration. John's enlightenment is portrayed in his ability to focus on his surroundings and adjust their contrast, seemingly by applying Photoshop filters. It's a far cry from the analogue in The Razor's Edge, which is much more wonderfully subtle and nuanced. And John's revelations occur only when he isn't doing everything in his power to be caught by local guerrillas. You'd think having been a public school teacher, he'd be savvier in war zones.
I confess I watched only most, not all, of this movie: I read the book, I know how it ends, and this version offered no original interpretation worth pursuing. In this regard, popular opinion of this film is on my side, which suggest perhaps the medium just isn't built for this kind of mind- or soul-bending. I've discovered some very dramatic, powerful, and touching films, such as Wit, but none that were outright intended to be spiritual in nature. (Indigo, Conversations With God, and What the Bleep? were all snoozers, in my opinion.) I love the topic, just not in this medium. Can someone prove me wrong?